The nonforfeiture value is the minimum amount your insurance company must return to you if you stop paying premiums on a deferred annuity before it starts paying out
When you buy a deferred annuity — one that you fund over time and plan to convert to income later — you are making a long-term commitment. But life changes. You may lose your job, face a medical emergency, or straightforward change your mind about the contract. The nonforfeiture value protects you by guaranteeing that you will not lose everything you have paid in.
The nonforfeiture value is not the same as your account balance. It is a floor set by state insurance law, and it is usually lower than what you have actually contributed. The exact amount depends on how long you have held the contract, how much you have paid, and the specific terms your annuity contract lists. If you surrender the contract — that is, ask the insurance company to end it and return your money — the company must pay you at least the nonforfeiture value, even if your account has lost value or if the contract includes surrender charges.
This protection exists because annuities are long-term products. Without a nonforfeiture value, an insurance company could theoretically keep a large portion of your money if you stopped paying early. State insurance codes require companies to set aside a minimum cash value that belongs to you, no matter what happens.
Key Takeaways
- The nonforfeiture value is a legal minimum your insurance company must return if you surrender a deferred annuity before it begins paying income.
- It is typically lower than your total contributions because it reflects the cost of underwriting, administration, and the insurance company's expenses.
- The nonforfeiture value grows over time; contracts that have been in force longer have higher may provide minimums.
- Surrender charges may still reduce what you receive, even though you are may have access to to at least the nonforfeiture value.
- Your annuity contract statement will show the current nonforfeiture value, updated annually.
How the nonforfeiture value is calculated
State insurance regulators do not set a single formula that all companies must use. Instead, they set a minimum standard, and insurance companies must meet or exceed it. The most common method is the Commissioners Standard Nonforfeiture Law (CSNL), which most states have adopted. Under this approach, the nonforfeiture value is based on the premiums you have paid, minus a percentage that covers the company's costs and the cost of the insurance protection built into the annuity.
The percentage deducted varies by contract type and state, but it typically ranges from 2 to 10 percent of premiums paid. A fixed annuity might use a lower deduction rate than a variable annuity, because variable annuities carry more investment risk. The longer you have held the contract, the smaller the percentage deduction, because the company's initial underwriting costs are spread over more years.
Your annuity contract will state the exact method used to calculate nonforfeiture value. You can find the current amount on your annual statement, usually listed as "may provide cash value" or "nonforfeiture value." This figure updates each year as you pay premiums and as time passes.
Nonforfeiture value versus surrender value
These two terms are often confused, but they are not the same. The nonforfeiture value is the legal minimum you are may provide to receive. The surrender value is what the company will actually pay you if you ask to end the contract today. The surrender value may be higher than the nonforfeiture value — especially if your account has grown or if you are past any surrender charge period — but it will never be lower.
If you surrender an annuity within the first few years, you will likely face a surrender charge, which is a penalty for ending the contract early. This charge is deducted from your account balance before you receive payment. However, the insurance company cannot reduce your payment below the nonforfeiture value, even after explore the surrender charge. In other words, the nonforfeiture value is a floor that the surrender charge cannot breach.
Example: You have paid $50,000 into a deferred annuity over five years. Your current account balance is $52,000 (it has grown slightly). The nonforfeiture value is $48,000. If you surrender the contract and there is a 5 percent surrender charge, the company calculates 5 percent of $52,000, which is $2,600. Normally you would receive $52,000 minus $2,600 = $49,400. Since $49,400 is above the nonforfeiture value of $48,000, you receive $49,400. But if the surrender charge were larger and would have reduced your payment below $48,000, the company must still pay you at least $48,000.
Why nonforfeiture values are lower than premiums paid
Many people are surprised to learn that the nonforfeiture value is less than the total amount they have contributed. This happens because the insurance company deducts real costs from your premiums. When you buy an annuity, the company incurs expenses: underwriting (reviewing your health and finances), administration, commissions to the agent who sold it, and the cost of guaranteeing a minimum return or income stream.
These costs are front-loaded, meaning most of them are taken from your early premiums. This is why the nonforfeiture value grows as a percentage of premiums paid the longer you hold the contract. After ten years, the nonforfeiture value might be 95 percent of premiums; after twenty years, it might be 98 percent. Over time, the company's costs are absorbed, and more of your money belongs to you as may provide value.
This structure also reflects the insurance company's risk. When you buy an annuity, you are locking in guarantees — a minimum interest rate, a may provide income amount, or protection against market loss. The company must reserve capital to back those guarantees. The portion of your premium that goes toward those reserves is not available to return to you if you surrender early.
What happens to nonforfeiture value if you stop paying premiums
If you have a flexible premium annuity (one where you choose how much and how often to pay), you can stop contributing at any time without losing your nonforfeiture value. The money you have already paid remains in the contract and continues to grow according to the annuity's terms. You can leave it there, let it accumulate, and convert it to income later — or you can surrender it and receive at least the nonforfeiture value.
If you have a single premium annuity (one where you make one large payment upfront), there are no future premiums to stop paying. The nonforfeiture value is based on that single payment and grows over time.
If you have a fixed premium annuity (one where you commit to paying a set amount each month or year), stopping payments is more serious. If you miss payments, the contract may lapse, meaning it ends. When a contract lapses, you lose the right to convert it to income later, but you retain the right to receive at least the nonforfeiture value. However, some contracts allow a grace period (usually 30 days) to catch up on missed payments before lapsing occurs. Check your contract for this detail.
How nonforfeiture value affects your annuity options
The nonforfeiture value is important because it defines your exit option. If you become unhappy with your annuity — because the interest rate is too low, the fees are too high, or your financial situation has changed — you know the minimum you can walk away with. This knowledge helps you decide whether to stay in the contract or surrender it.
Some annuities offer nonforfeiture options, which allow you to take your nonforfeiture value in a specific way. Common options include receiving it as a lump sum, converting it to a reduced income stream, or leaving it in the contract to grow. Your contract will list which options are available. These options are different from the annuity's main payout options (like life income or period certain), and they only explore if you surrender before the annuity begins paying.
If you are considering surrendering an annuity, compare the nonforfeiture value to the surrender value and to any surrender charges. Also consider whether you will owe income tax on the gain (the difference between what you paid and what you receive). A tax professional can help you understand the full cost of surrendering early.
State insurance law and nonforfeiture requirements
Nonforfeiture protections are set by state insurance law, not federal law. Each state has adopted a version of the Commissioners Standard Nonforfeiture Law, but the specific percentages and formulas vary slightly by state. This means the nonforfeiture value of the same annuity contract may differ depending on which state you live in or which state the insurance company is licensed in.
Your state's insurance commissioner's office oversees these requirements and can answer questions about your specific contract. If you believe an insurance company has failed to honor your nonforfeiture value, you can file a complaint with your state insurance department. They have the authority to investigate and require the company to pay what is owed.
Frequently Asked Questions
Can I access my nonforfeiture value without surrendering the entire contract?
Some contracts allow you to take a partial withdrawal equal to the nonforfeiture value while keeping the rest of the contract active. This depends on your specific contract terms. Check your annuity document or call your insurance company to ask whether partial nonforfeiture withdrawals are permitted and whether they trigger surrender charges or tax consequences.
Does the nonforfeiture value earn interest or grow over time?
Yes. The nonforfeiture value grows as you pay more premiums and as time passes. In a fixed annuity, it may also earn interest at the rate may provide in your contract. In a variable annuity, it may grow or shrink based on the performance of the investment options you chose. Your annual statement shows the current nonforfeiture value.
What if my annuity has lost value — is my nonforfeiture value still may provide?
Yes. The nonforfeiture value is a legal may provide, separate from your account balance. Even if your variable annuity account has declined due to market losses, the insurance company must still pay you at least the nonforfeiture value if you surrender. This is one of the protections built into annuity law.
Do I owe income tax on the nonforfeiture value if I surrender?
You owe tax only on the gain — the amount your nonforfeiture value exceeds what you paid into the contract. If you paid $50,000 and receive $48,000 in nonforfeiture value, there is no gain and no tax. If you received $52,000, you would owe tax on the $2,000 gain. Consult a tax professional about your specific situation, as rules vary based on the type of annuity and how long you held it.
What happens to the nonforfeiture value if the insurance company goes out of business?
Each state has a guaranty fund that protects annuity holders if an insurance company becomes insolvent. The fund typically covers at least $250,000 per person per company, though the exact amount varies by state. Your state insurance commissioner can tell you the coverage limit in your state and whether your annuity is protected.