What a forfeiture account is and why it matters to you
A forfeiture account in a cash balance pension is a pool of money created when employees leave the plan before they are fully vested. When you forfeit your unvested balance—the portion of your employer's contributions you have not yet earned the right to keep—that money does not disappear. Instead, it goes into a forfeiture account that the plan uses to reduce future employer contributions or to pay plan expenses.
This affects you in two ways. First, if you are still employed and vested, forfeiture accounts can lower the contributions your employer needs to make on your behalf, which may reduce the growth of your own account balance. Second, if you leave the company before vesting, understanding how forfeiture works helps you know exactly what you lose and what you keep.
The forfeiture account itself is not your money and you cannot access it directly. It belongs to the plan as a whole and is managed by the plan administrator according to rules set out in the plan document and federal tax law.
Key Takeaways
- Forfeiture accounts hold the unvested portions of employee balances when workers leave before becoming fully vested.
- Your employer can use forfeiture money to reduce its own contributions to the plan or to pay plan administrative costs.
- If you are vested, forfeitures by other employees may slow the growth of your balance because your employer contributes less.
- The vesting schedule in your plan document determines exactly when you own your employer's contributions and when you forfeit them.
- Forfeiture accounts are tracked separately and reported on the plan's annual Form 5500 filing with the IRS.
How forfeiture accounts reduce employer contributions
When your employer makes contributions to your cash balance account, those contributions are tax-deductible for the company. But the employer does not have to contribute the full amount every year if the plan has a forfeiture account with money in it. Instead, the employer can use forfeiture money to offset part or all of its required contribution.
This is called a forfeiture credit. If the plan has $50,000 in forfeitures and the employer would normally contribute $200,000 that year, the employer might contribute only $150,000 in new money and use the $50,000 forfeiture credit to make up the difference. The total amount going into employee accounts stays the same, but the employer's out-of-pocket cost is lower.
The plan administrator decides how to use forfeitures each year. Some plans use them to reduce employer contributions first. Others use them to pay plan expenses like recordkeeping, actuarial fees, or trustee costs. The rules for how forfeitures are used must be spelled out in the plan document.
When you forfeit your balance and what you keep
Your cash balance account has two parts: your own contributions (if the plan allows them) and your employer's contributions. You always own 100 percent of your own contributions, no matter when you leave. The employer's contributions are subject to a vesting schedule.
A vesting schedule is a timeline that determines when you own the employer's contributions. Common schedules include cliff vesting (you own nothing until a set date, then you own 100 percent) and graded vesting (you own an increasing percentage each year). For example, a three-year cliff schedule means you own zero percent of employer contributions if you leave before three years, and 100 percent if you leave after three years.
When you leave before you are fully vested, the unvested portion goes into the forfeiture account. You receive a distribution of only the vested portion. If you were 40 percent vested and your account balance was $100,000, you would receive $40,000 and the remaining $60,000 would be forfeited.
How to find your vesting schedule and forfeiture rules
Your vesting schedule is in the plan document, which your employer or plan administrator must provide to you. You can request it by asking your human resources or benefits department for the Summary Plan Description (SPD). The SPD explains the plan in plain language and includes the vesting schedule, when contributions are made, and how forfeitures are used.
You can also ask for the full plan document itself, though it is longer and more technical. Both documents are free and the plan must provide them within 30 days of your request. If your employer offers the plan through a third-party administrator, you can contact that administrator directly.
Look for a section titled "Vesting" or "Forfeiture" in the SPD. It will tell you the exact schedule—for instance, "100 percent vesting after three years of service" or "20 percent per year for five years." This tells you precisely what percentage of employer contributions you own at any point in your employment.
The tax treatment of forfeiture accounts
Forfeiture accounts are not taxable income to you because the money was never yours. You do not report them on your tax return and you do not owe income tax on them. The forfeiture happens at the plan level, not at the individual level.
However, forfeiture accounts do affect the plan's overall tax status. The plan must track forfeitures separately and report them on Form 5500, the annual filing the plan makes with the IRS and Department of Labor. If forfeitures are used to reduce employer contributions, that reduces the employer's tax deduction for that year.
If you receive a distribution of your vested balance when you leave, that distribution is taxable to you in the year you receive it (unless you roll it into an IRA or another may have access to plan). The forfeiture of your unvested balance is not taxable because you never had a right to it.
What happens to forfeiture accounts when you are rehired
If you leave a cash balance plan and are later rehired by the same employer, the forfeiture is permanent—you do not get that money back. However, your new account balance starts fresh. Your employer begins making new contributions to your account based on your new hire date, and you begin a new vesting schedule.
There is one exception: if you are rehired within a certain period (usually five years, depending on the plan), you may be able to restore your prior service for vesting purposes. This means your years of service before you left count toward your new vesting schedule. But the forfeited balance itself does not return—only the service credit does.
Check your plan document or ask your benefits department about the rehire rules specific to your plan. Some plans allow service restoration and some do not.
How forfeiture accounts affect your retirement income
If you stay with your employer until you are fully vested, forfeiture accounts do not directly reduce your own balance. However, they do affect how much your employer contributes each year. When the plan uses forfeitures to offset employer contributions, your employer is putting in less new money, which means the plan's total assets grow more slowly.
This slower growth can affect the plan's funding status and, in some cases, the interest rate used to credit your account. Cash balance plans credit your account with a stated interest rate each year (set by the plan document, often tied to Treasury rates). If the plan is underfunded, the plan sponsor might lower the interest rate in future years, which would reduce the credits to your account.
The impact is usually small if you stay employed long enough to become fully vested. The real risk is leaving before vesting—in that case, you lose a portion of your account balance permanently.
Frequently Asked Questions
Can I get my forfeited balance back if I leave and come back?
No. Once your unvested balance is forfeited, it belongs to the plan and you cannot recover it, even if you are rehired. However, some plans allow you to restore your prior service for vesting purposes if you are rehired within five years, which means your new vesting schedule starts sooner. Check your plan document for rehire rules.
Does the forfeiture account reduce the interest credited to my account?
Not directly. Your account is credited with the interest rate stated in the plan document. However, if the plan uses forfeitures to reduce employer contributions, the plan's overall funding may be affected, which could influence the interest rate the plan uses in future years if the plan becomes underfunded.
What if I am vested but the plan has a large forfeiture account?
A large forfeiture account means your employer will contribute less new money that year, which slows the growth of all employee accounts, including yours. Over time, this can reduce your final balance. You cannot control this, but you can ask your benefits department how forfeitures are being used and whether the plan's funding is on track.
Is the forfeiture account reported anywhere I can see it?
Yes. The plan's Form 5500 annual filing, which is public, shows the forfeiture account balance and how it was used that year. You can search for your plan's Form 5500 on the Department of Labor website. However, the form is technical and may be difficult to read without help.
What happens to the forfeiture account if the plan is terminated?
If the plan terminates, any remaining forfeiture account balance is distributed to remaining participants and beneficiaries in proportion to their account balances, or used to pay plan expenses. The exact method depends on the plan document and how the termination is structured.